Model Change Bulletin MCB#1 09/09/95 ISCST3 (dated 95250) ISCLT3 (dated 95250) This Model Change Bulletin initiates the use of the Industrial Source Complex Dispersion Model (ISC3). Changes from the ISCST2 (dated 93109) and ISCLT2 (dated 93109) include (1) a new area source algorithm, (2) a revised dry deposition algorithm, (3) a wet deposition algorithm, (4) COMPLEX1 algorithms for complex terrain calculations, and (5) a pit retention algorithm. A detailed description of ISCST3 and ISCLT3 files and their contents is contained in the README.TXT file, located with the *.EXEs. The ISCEV3 model has not been updated at this time. It is currently being updated and a SCRAM Alert will notify users of its availability. Likewise, the ISC2VOL3.ZIP file was not updated. Due to budget restrictions, there are no imminent plans to revise the programming guide (ISC2VOL3.ZIP). The following is a list of changes which have occurred between the Beta Testing versions of ISCST3/ISCLT3 (dated 95200) and the current versions of ISCST3/ISCLT3 (dated 95250): ISCST3 (1) Fixed problem with summary tables for short term averages, which occurred when requesting non-consecutive high values (e.g. OU RECTABLE FIRST SECOND SIXTH), (2) Fixed error for open pit sources with release heights above the base of the pit, and (3) Added fatal error message for open pit source with no particle categories specified. ISCLT3 (1) Same as items (2) and (3) above. This program will henceforth be identified by its name and a Julian date, i.e.: ISCST3 (dated 95250). Future changes to this model will be identified by an updated Julian date found on the first line of the model source code and followed by a reference to a SCRAM BBS Model Change Bulletin (MCB#n) which will explain the nature and contents of the changes. All Model Change Bulletins for this program will always be available for back reference on this BBS. In the future, notification of changes (MCBs) to this prgram will be made in the SCRAM ALERTS section of this BBS immediately following the LOGON procedure. ****************************************************** * * * Amendment #1 to Model Change Bulletin #1 * * 04/17/96 * * * ****************************************************** The purpose of this amendment is to alert users of ISC3 that it is possible to inadvertently use the model in a way that was not intended. When a user is estimating air quality credits (e.g., PSD increment expansion) due to source shut down or emissions reductions, negative emissions can be input to the model as part of the calculations. While this approach is widely used in flat terrain applications, serious reservations have been expressed regarding its use with complex terrain screening techniques. Due to the inherent conservative nature of these screening techniques, excessive air quality credits may be estimated. The current version of ISC3 has the capability of using complex terrain screening for estimating air quality credits. Although the Guideline on Air Quality Models (Revised) does not specifically provide guidance on using models to estimate air quality credits, there are precedents for such usage. The EPA Model Clearinghouse responded to this issue in a November 6, 1992 memorandum to EPA Region I (see Model Clearinghouse in Area H on the main SCRAM menu, then select Current Memos, file CFYM#77.TXT). This was in response to a proposal to use a screening model to estimate air quality or concentration credits in intermediate terrain due to emission reductions. Note that intermediate terrain is defined as the terrain between stack height and plume height. Also note that when screening modeling is conducted in the intermediate terrain area to calculate concentration estimates, the GAQM recommends that concentration estimates be calculated for each receptor and hour with both a simple terrain model (with terrain cut-off at stack top) and a complex terrain screening model. The larger of the model estimates would then be selected for that hour. EPA Region X has presented a method that would allow ISC3 to be applied for estimating air quality credits consistent with the November 6, 1992 Model Clearinghouse memorandum. This method consists of coding changes to the ISC3 which were developed by RTP Environmental Associates. Since there may be other cases where a similar modeling analysis for concentrations credits is necessary, the coding changes submitted by Region X are available in Area F of SCRAM BBS - Topics for Review/Comment. Implementation of these coding changes is the responsibility of the user and would require recompilation of the program. However, the Agency has not made a decision on the acceptability of these changes for a formal modification of ISC3 and they should only be used on a case-by-case basis with the concurrence of the appropriate regulatory agencies. Comments on the accuracy of the code and its compatibility with the November 6, 1992 memorandum should be directed to Dennis Doll (US EPA) via SCRAM email or INTERNET doll.dennis@epamail.epa.gov .